• Our work

      Themes

    • Brexit and Parliament
    • Future Parliament
    • Governance of Parliament
    • Making better law
    • Parliaments around the world
    • Parliamentary scrutiny
    • Political engagement
    • Representation
    • publications

    • Publications Home
    • Procedural and constitutional guides
    • Briefings
    • Reports
    • Submissions
    • projects

    • Delegated Legislation Review
    • Audit of Political Engagement
    • services

    • Statutory Instrument Tracker®
  • About

      about

      who we are

    • What we do
    • Our history
    • Our governance
    • contact

    • Our people
    • Contact us
    • Contacts for the media
    • careers

    • Jobs
    • subscribe

    • Insight Notes newsletter
    • Hansard Society newsletter
  • Blog
  • News
  • Events
  • Journal
  • Scholars
Hansard Society logoHansard Society logo
  • Our work

    • Themes

      • Brexit and Parliament
      • Future Parliament
      • Governance of Parliament
      • Making better law
      • Parliaments around the world
      • Parliamentary scrutiny
      • Political engagement
      • Representation
    • publications

      • Publications Home
      • Procedural and constitutional guides
      • Briefings
      • Reports
      • Submissions

      projects

      • Delegated Legislation Review
      • Audit of Political Engagement

      services

      • Statutory Instrument Tracker®
  • About

    • about

        who we are

      • What we do
      • Our history
      • Our governance
      • contact

      • Our people
      • Contact us
      • Contacts for the media
      • careers

      • Jobs
      • subscribe

      • Insight Notes newsletter
      • Hansard Society newsletter
      • Join our newsletter

        Get the latest updates on our research and events, together with expert comment and analysis, delivered to your inbox each month.

        You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

        Thank you!

        You have been successfully added to our newsletter list.

        Follow us

        :( Oops! Something went wrong...

        Please reload the page and try again.

        Insight Notes

        Subscribe to our regular Insight Notes on parliamentary data, procedures and the legislative process at Westminster, including updates on Brexit Statutory Instruments - in your inbox every sitting Monday afternoon.

        You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

        Thank you!

        You have been successfully added to our Insight Notes email list.

        Follow us

        :( Oops! Something went wrong...

        Please reload the page and try again.

      Follow us

  • Blog

    Blog

    • blog

      • Despatch Box Blog
  • News

    News

    • news

      • News Home
  • Events

    Events

    • events

      • Events
  • Journal

    Journal

    • journal

      • Parliamentary Affairs
  • Scholars

    Scholars

    Photo of a nurse
    publications / briefings / 2021

    The Health and Care Bill: Delegated Powers

    Share this

    Ahead of the Health and Care Bill’s Committee stage in the House of Commons, this briefing paper focuses on five clauses in the Bill that contain delegated powers that are of particular concern and that highlight different aspects of the problems with the system of delegated powers.

    Download the briefing

    Download

    While the delegated powers in the Health and Care Bill might appear to be merely technical matters, in this as in most bills they raise important questions of constitutional, legal and procedural principle that matter, regardless of party allegiance or views on the policy merits of the bill.

    The scope and design of the delegation of power sought in any bill raise important questions for MPs that go to the heart of their role as legislators.

    For example:

    • To what extent are MPs willing to continue accepting the troubling arrogation of power by the executive (by successive governments) at the expense of Parliament?
    • What scrutiny or other safeguards do Members think are desirable or necessary to constrain use of delegated powers? Given the inadequacy of scrutiny procedures that apply to delegated legislation in the House of Commons, can they really remedy a delegation of legislative power otherwise deemed unacceptable?
    • If Parliament accepts controversial powers in a bill, it creates a precedent that may be used by government to justify taking similar powers in other bills in the future. However, if Parliament has reluctantly accepted a power in exceptional circumstances - for example, during the Brexit process when there was a need to legislate at speed - are MPs content for Ministers to rely on that precedent for the establishment of new powers?
    • The inclusion of ‘Henry VIII powers’ enabling Ministers to amend or repeal primary legislation by Statutory Instrument challenges the constitutional principle that Parliament is sovereign; that it is the sole legislative authority with the power to create, amend or repeal any law. How content are MPs for such powers to continue to be a relatively common feature of the law?
    • How much discretion do MPs think should be conferred on Ministers by the legislature? Ministers may use broadly defined and ambiguously worded powers in ways that that go beyond the original intention of the legislation. How content are MPs that such powers continue to be claimed by the executive, particularly when in many instances such powers will be available to Ministers in future governments of a different political stripe, possibly decades later, and may therefore be used by Ministers with radically different policy objectives from those who sought the powers in the first place?
    • Do MPs think that government should be granted ‘reserve’ or ‘holding’ powers, the use of which is not fully explained or defined, simply because it is administratively convenient or because Ministers may desire freedom to act at a later date? Are MPs content that Ministerial claims of exigency and convenience should trump parliamentary scrutiny?
    • When Ministers acknowledge that the relevant policy development process - particularly the consultation stage - is unfinished, should they nonetheless be granted powers to act in that area of policy?

    If MPs are solicitous of the proper role and function of Parliament and their responsibilities as legislators, then the answers to these questions should inform the debate about the scope of, and safeguards applied to, each clause in a bill that contains a proposed delegation of power. Changes which tighten the use of powers, limit the extent of discretion, incorporate scrutiny safeguards, or resist the gravitational pull of precedent, are designed to buttress the role of Parliament in scrutinising future executive action and regulations; they need not interfere with or prevent the implementation of the intended policy.

    Outline of the briefing

    The briefing falls into two main parts:

    • The first, after an overview of the Bill, summarises our key thematic concerns about some of the delegated powers in the Health and Care Bill.
    • The second provides a detailed analysis of the clauses of concern, drawing on the Bill and the Explanatory Notes and Delegated Powers Memorandum (DPM) that accompany the legislation.

    The five clauses of concern are:

    • Clause 14 - People for whom Integrated Care Boards have core responsibility
    • Clause 68 - Procurement regulations
    • Clause 87 - Power to transfer functions between bodies
    • Clause 120 - International healthcare arrangements
    • Clause 125 - Advertising of less healthy food and drink

    Our analysis draws heavily on ‘legislative standards’ which we have derived from reports of the House of Lords Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee (DPRRC). The DPRRC is an influential committee and provides the nearest thing to a form of ‘jurisprudence’ (or ‘legisprudence’) in the area of delegated powers.

    This paper was produced by Dheemanth Vangimalla with assistance from Dr Brigid Fowler, Dr Ruth Fox and Dr Tom West.


    The research for this paper was funded by the Legal Education Foundation as part of the Hansard Society’s Delegated Legislation Review.


    Enjoy reading this? Please consider sharing it

    Related

    Tractor spraying chemicals on crops
    blog / 08.04.22

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?

    Bird's-eye view of the Palace of Westminster, UK Houses of Parliament
    blog / 04.04.22

    Constitution and Governance in the UK: Parliament and Legislation

    Photo of a clock showing the countdown to Brexit
    news / articles

    In the rush to prepare for Brexit, parliamentary scrutiny will suffer

    projects

    Delegated Legislation Review

    Big ben with data graphic superimposed on top of it
    projects

    Westminster Lens: Parliamentary Data

    Cover page image for Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation
    publica… / reports / 2022

    Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation

    Houses of Parliament, Westminster, UK
    publica… / submissions / 2022

    Written evidence to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee: Retained EU Law: Where next?

    Parliament with icons overlay
    services

    Statutory Instrument Tracker®

    Join our newsletter

    Get the latest updates on our research and events, together with expert comment and analysis, delivered to your inbox each month.

    You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

    Thank you!

    You have been successfully added to our newsletter list.

    Follow us

    :( Oops! Something went wrong...

    Please reload the page and try again.

    Top three

    Vladimir Putin address to citizens 2 April 2020 Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vladimir_Putin_address_to_citizens_2020-04-02.jpg Attribution: 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) Source: The Russian Presidential Press and Information Office (http://kremlin.ru/)
    blog / 22.02.22

    Russia-Ukraine crisis: how are sanctions Regulations made and how does Parliament scrutinise them?

    Tractor spraying chemicals on crops
    blog / 08.04.22

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?

    projects

    Delegated Legislation Review

    Latest

    Photo of Acts of Parliament in the Parliamentary Archives, Houses of Parliament, Westminster
    publications / reports / 2022

    Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation

    The scope and design of the delegation of legislative powers in any Bill affects the long-term balance of power between…Parliament and Government. The House of Lords Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee (DPRRC) scrutinises all such delegation. This report distils standards for the delegation of powers from 101 DPRRC reports from 2017 to 2021.

    Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation
    Tractor spraying chemicals on crops
    blog / 08.04.22

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?

    A Statutory Instrument comes into force on 11 April that changes the legal requirements for the release of certain types… of genetically modified plants. Some argue that the changes should have been made by primary, rather than delegated, legislation. Where does the boundary between the two lie?

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?
    Bird's-eye view of the Palace of Westminster, UK Houses of Parliament
    blog / 04.04.22

    Constitution and Governance in the UK: Parliament and Legislation

    The Brexit process, the pandemic and the approach of the Johnson Government have all tended towards Parliament’s margina…lisation and the accretion of executive power. For UK in a Changing Europe’s report on the constitutional landscape, we show how – in the legislative process and control of public money and executive action, including delegated legislation.

    Constitution and Governance in the UK: Parliament and Legislation
    Roman Abramovich's yacht
    blog / 15.03.22

    What role does the UK Parliament play in sanctioning an individual? [Video]

    Sanctions are imposed on an individual in two stages - by Ministers first making regulations and secondly designating th…e individual, using a power in those regulations. Parliament has a role in the first stage, but not the second.

    What role does the UK Parliament play in sanctioning an individual? [Video]
    publications / submissions / 2022

    Written evidence to the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee: the Restorat…ion and Renewal of Parliament

    Our submission to the Public Accounts Committee highlighted the financial and practical challenges that MPs face in deci…ding the fate of Parliament’s Restoration and Renewal programme. We particularly questioned the viability of the proposal to continue operating the House of Commons Chamber in the middle of a building site.

    Written evidence to the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee: the Restoration and Renewal of Parliament
    Houses of Parliament, Westminster, UK
    publications / submissions / 2022

    Written evidence to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee: Retained E…U Law: Where next?

    Our submission to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee inquiry into retained EU law (REUL) placed the issue…in the context of our Delegated Legislation Review. It discussed REUL’s diversity and amendment; the people and organisations to whom REUL amendment may matter; and parliamentary scrutiny of delegated legislation arising from amending REUL.

    Written evidence to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee: Retained EU Law: Where next?
    Prev
    Next
    • Recent pages
      • The Health and Care Bill: Delegated Powerspublications / briefings
    • Home
    • Contact us
    • What we do
    • Jobs
    • Privacy policy
    • Site map

    Join our newsletter

    Get the latest updates on our research and events, together with expert comment and analysis, delivered to your inbox each month.

    You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

    Thank you!

    You have been successfully added to our newsletter list.

    Follow us

    :( Oops! Something went wrong...

    Please reload the page and try again.

    Copyright © 2022 Hansard Society • Charity No: 1091364 • Registration No: 4332105.