• Our work

      Themes

    • Brexit and Parliament
    • Future Parliament
    • Governance of Parliament
    • Making better law
    • Parliaments around the world
    • Parliamentary scrutiny
    • Political engagement
    • Representation
    • publications

    • Publications Home
    • Procedural and constitutional guides
    • Briefings
    • Reports
    • Submissions
    • projects

    • Delegated Legislation Review
    • Audit of Political Engagement
    • services

    • Statutory Instrument Tracker®
  • About

      about

      who we are

    • What we do
    • Our history
    • Our governance
    • contact

    • Our people
    • Contact us
    • Contacts for the media
    • careers

    • Jobs
    • subscribe

    • Insight Notes newsletter
    • Hansard Society newsletter
  • Blog
  • News
  • Events
  • Journal
  • Scholars
Hansard Society logoHansard Society logo
  • Our work

    • Themes

      • Brexit and Parliament
      • Future Parliament
      • Governance of Parliament
      • Making better law
      • Parliaments around the world
      • Parliamentary scrutiny
      • Political engagement
      • Representation
    • publications

      • Publications Home
      • Procedural and constitutional guides
      • Briefings
      • Reports
      • Submissions

      projects

      • Delegated Legislation Review
      • Audit of Political Engagement

      services

      • Statutory Instrument Tracker®
  • About

    • about

        who we are

      • What we do
      • Our history
      • Our governance
      • contact

      • Our people
      • Contact us
      • Contacts for the media
      • careers

      • Jobs
      • subscribe

      • Insight Notes newsletter
      • Hansard Society newsletter
      • Join our newsletter

        Get the latest updates on our research and events, together with expert comment and analysis, delivered to your inbox each month.

        You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

        Thank you!

        You have been successfully added to our newsletter list.

        Follow us

        :( Oops! Something went wrong...

        Please reload the page and try again.

        Insight Notes

        Subscribe to our regular Insight Notes on parliamentary data, procedures and the legislative process at Westminster, including updates on Brexit Statutory Instruments - in your inbox every sitting Monday afternoon.

        You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

        Thank you!

        You have been successfully added to our Insight Notes email list.

        Follow us

        :( Oops! Something went wrong...

        Please reload the page and try again.

      Follow us

  • Blog

    Blog

    • blog

      • Despatch Box Blog
  • News

    News

    • news

      • News Home
  • Events

    Events

    • events

      • Events
  • Journal

    Journal

    • journal

      • Parliamentary Affairs
  • Scholars

    Scholars

    The Palace of Westminster and the River Thames, UK Houses of Parliament
    blog / 18.11.21

    Parliament is under-scrutinising swathes of important law. But the problem can be fixed

    Share this

    Delegated legislation may not be glamorous but it is essential to how our democracy works. Time to treat it accordingly.

    Profile Photo of Tom West, researcher, Hansard Society

    Dr Tom West

    Researcher, Hansard Society

    Tom joined the Hansard Society in July 2021 and is focussed on its programme of work on how Parliament legislates, in particular being responsible for the co-ordination of its Delegated Legislation Review. Tom conducts research for the Society on legislative processes and procedures and supports its collaboration and partnership with other stakeholders and networks active in the field.

    Previously, Tom was employed at the UN in the secretariat of the Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee, an international law body tasked with assessing States’ compliance with their obligations relating to transparency, participation and justice in environmental decision-making. He has also given evidence to Parliamentary Committees and has engaged with the design and passage of new legislation through his role at environmental law NGO ClientEarth, where he led their work in response to Brexit. During that time he was a member of BIICL’s Expert Working Group on the EU (Withdrawal) Bill and the Rule of Law.

    Having first studied for a BSc in Mathematics at the University of Warwick, Tom then turned to law via an MSc in Law and Environmental Science and a PhD in international human rights and environmental law at the University of Nottingham, which he completed in 2017.

    This piece was first published in Prospect online on 10 November 2021.


    “It’s pretty bloody boring to sit on a statutory instrument committee if you could be on Have I Got News for You,” Labour MP Angela Eagle remarked at the recent launch of the Hansard Society’s Delegated Legislation Review. The comment was made with more than a little personal experience and at least half a raised eyebrow as MPs debated holding ministers to account for the hundreds of statutory instruments that are laid before parliament each session.

    But the discussion over the course of the event laid bare an important truth: with their time under pressure from constituency, party and parliamentary obligations, MPs derive very little professional advantage from prioritising their constitutional duty as legislators. This holds particularly true for their scrutiny of delegated legislation—the rules and regulations found in statutory instruments made under powers entrusted by parliament to government ministers.

    Eagle was a member of the European Statutory Instruments Committee during the Brexit process, an experience she described as like being “sent to Alcatraz”: thankless work scrutinising hundreds of often highly technical SIs that ensured the statute book was ready for our departure from the EU. There is no political reward for such mind-numbing legislative graft away from the spotlight. For better or worse, the hard slog of legislative scrutiny seldom hits the headlines, so constituents, party colleagues and journalists know little about the work that MPs are doing on the legislative committee corridor.

    The multi-faceted role of an MP today is highly demanding, running the gamut from local constituency social worker to national legislator, all in the face of round-the-clock demands from the media and the public. How MPs choose to spend their time and what they choose to prioritise therefore involves difficult choices and trade-offs.

    But nowhere is the mismatch between incentive, impact and importance greater than with delegated legislation.

    Understandably, scrutiny of the latest set of technical regulations on egg labelling, aircraft safety or reporting requirements for children in care is not the most enticing of tasks: after all, who will ever know that their MP stayed up late checking the legal cross-references and the impact assessment?

    But these statutory instruments, and their scrutiny, matter. They are the legislation of everyday life, affecting millions of citizens and organisations across the country. A minister’s ability to put in place lockdowns and other wide-ranging restrictions at the stroke of a pen during the pandemic saw the issue receive more attention than usual. But pre-pandemic (and indeed pre-Brexit), the inadequacies in the system for scrutinising delegated legislation in the House of Commons in particular were already being lamented by constitutional commentators and parliamentary committees alike.

    The problems are manifold: there is no sensible correlation between the content of an SI and the level of scrutiny it is subjected to. Government control of the House of Commons agenda restricts MPs’ ability to secure debates on SIs. Scrutiny procedures are superficial and often a waste of time. There is no penalty for poor-quality supporting documentation. And the variety of procedures and their terminology is confusing and overly complex. Taken together, these factors lead to a system devoid of any meaningful oversight of ministerial lawmaking.

    An MP’s job is also made harder by the lack of resources to support their work. Compared to the resourcing of scrutiny of policy (via subject-specific select committees) and of public finances (via the House of Commons Scrutiny Unit and the National Audit Office), the resourcing of the legislative process in the Commons is poor.

    That’s why the Hansard Society is developing detailed proposals for a new scrutiny system for this important body of law. Over the course of the next year, we will be looking at the different ways in which the system could be improved for parliament, for government and for the public.

    But any new system has to work with the grain of politics. Lawmaking is not a purely technical exercise and a technocratic solution is no solution at all. Legislative scrutiny is an inherently political process and needs informed and engaged politicians at the heart of it. A better scrutiny system will be one that provides MPs with the tools they need to assess, understand and address the issues that matter most to their constituents.

    It will also incentivise MPs to be active and constructive when reviewing delegated legislation, confident in the knowledge that their efforts will not be in vain. Scrutiny of legislation that affects us all shouldn’t be such a burden that MPs feel it’s the political equivalent of being sent to Alcatraz.


    Enjoy reading this? Please consider sharing it

    Featured

    projects

    Delegated Legislation Review

    Panel discussion during the launch event for the Delegated Legislation Review
    events / 02.11.21

    Launch of the Hansard Society Delegated Legislation Review

    Related

    Tractor spraying chemicals on crops
    blog / 08.04.22

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?

    Bird's-eye view of the Palace of Westminster, UK Houses of Parliament
    blog / 04.04.22

    Constitution and Governance in the UK: Parliament and Legislation

    Photo of a clock showing the countdown to Brexit
    news / articles

    In the rush to prepare for Brexit, parliamentary scrutiny will suffer

    Big ben with data graphic superimposed on top of it
    projects

    Westminster Lens: Parliamentary Data

    Cover page image for Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation
    publica… / reports / 2022

    Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation

    Houses of Parliament, Westminster, UK
    publica… / submissions / 2022

    Written evidence to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee: Retained EU Law: Where next?

    Parliament with icons overlay
    services

    Statutory Instrument Tracker®

    Join our newsletter

    Get the latest updates on our research and events, together with expert comment and analysis, delivered to your inbox each month.

    You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

    Thank you!

    You have been successfully added to our newsletter list.

    Follow us

    :( Oops! Something went wrong...

    Please reload the page and try again.

    Top three

    Vladimir Putin address to citizens 2 April 2020 Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vladimir_Putin_address_to_citizens_2020-04-02.jpg Attribution: 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) Source: The Russian Presidential Press and Information Office (http://kremlin.ru/)
    blog / 22.02.22

    Russia-Ukraine crisis: how are sanctions Regulations made and how does Parliament scrutinise them?

    Tractor spraying chemicals on crops
    blog / 08.04.22

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?

    projects

    Delegated Legislation Review

    Latest

    Photo of Acts of Parliament in the Parliamentary Archives, Houses of Parliament, Westminster
    publications / reports / 2022

    Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation

    The scope and design of the delegation of legislative powers in any Bill affects the long-term balance of power between…Parliament and Government. The House of Lords Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee (DPRRC) scrutinises all such delegation. This report distils standards for the delegation of powers from 101 DPRRC reports from 2017 to 2021.

    Compendium of Legislative Standards for Delegating Powers in Primary Legislation
    Tractor spraying chemicals on crops
    blog / 08.04.22

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?

    A Statutory Instrument comes into force on 11 April that changes the legal requirements for the release of certain types… of genetically modified plants. Some argue that the changes should have been made by primary, rather than delegated, legislation. Where does the boundary between the two lie?

    Genetically modified organisms: Primary or delegated legislation?
    Bird's-eye view of the Palace of Westminster, UK Houses of Parliament
    blog / 04.04.22

    Constitution and Governance in the UK: Parliament and Legislation

    The Brexit process, the pandemic and the approach of the Johnson Government have all tended towards Parliament’s margina…lisation and the accretion of executive power. For UK in a Changing Europe’s report on the constitutional landscape, we show how – in the legislative process and control of public money and executive action, including delegated legislation.

    Constitution and Governance in the UK: Parliament and Legislation
    Roman Abramovich's yacht
    blog / 15.03.22

    What role does the UK Parliament play in sanctioning an individual? [Video]

    Sanctions are imposed on an individual in two stages - by Ministers first making regulations and secondly designating th…e individual, using a power in those regulations. Parliament has a role in the first stage, but not the second.

    What role does the UK Parliament play in sanctioning an individual? [Video]
    publications / submissions / 2022

    Written evidence to the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee: the Restorat…ion and Renewal of Parliament

    Our submission to the Public Accounts Committee highlighted the financial and practical challenges that MPs face in deci…ding the fate of Parliament’s Restoration and Renewal programme. We particularly questioned the viability of the proposal to continue operating the House of Commons Chamber in the middle of a building site.

    Written evidence to the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee: the Restoration and Renewal of Parliament
    Houses of Parliament, Westminster, UK
    publications / submissions / 2022

    Written evidence to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee: Retained E…U Law: Where next?

    Our submission to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee inquiry into retained EU law (REUL) placed the issue…in the context of our Delegated Legislation Review. It discussed REUL’s diversity and amendment; the people and organisations to whom REUL amendment may matter; and parliamentary scrutiny of delegated legislation arising from amending REUL.

    Written evidence to the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee: Retained EU Law: Where next?
    Prev
    Next
    • Recent pages
      • Parliament is under-scrutinising swathes of important law. But the problem can be fixedblog
    • Home
    • Contact us
    • What we do
    • Jobs
    • Privacy policy
    • Site map

    Join our newsletter

    Get the latest updates on our research and events, together with expert comment and analysis, delivered to your inbox each month.

    You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy here.

    Thank you!

    You have been successfully added to our newsletter list.

    Follow us

    :( Oops! Something went wrong...

    Please reload the page and try again.

    Copyright © 2022 Hansard Society • Charity No: 1091364 • Registration No: 4332105.